Key Terms to Negotiate in Your Contract Manufacturing Agreement
A contract manufacturing agreement is what solidifies the understanding between you and your supplier. It ensures that both parties are aligned on expectations, responsibilities, and key deliverables. Without a well-defined contract, there is room for misinterpretation, which can lead to pricing disputes, production delays, quality issues, or IP-related issues.
This agreement is not just a formality, but it sets clear expectations for your supplier, outlining what needs to be done, how it should be done, and the standards that must be met. If certain terms are left vague or undefined, your supplier may act differently than you anticipate, leading to potential disruptions in your supply chain.
In this article, we’ll cover the essential terms to include in your contract manufacturing agreement, helping you negotiate a contract that protects your business and ensures a reliable, well-structured partnership with your supplier.
Pricing and Payment Terms
Pricing and payment terms are at the core of any contract manufacturing agreement. They define the financial relationship between you and your supplier, ensuring transparency and predictability in costs. A well-structured agreement prevents unexpected price changes and cash flow issues while setting the stage for long-term collaboration.
Minimum Order Quantities (MOQs)
Most suppliers require a minimum order quantity (MOQ), which is the minimum number of units they require for a purchase order. Your contract should clearly outline this MOQ, along with the price.
Pricing Structure
The agreement should specify whether pricing is fixed, subject to review, or dependent on material costs and exchange rates. Also, suppliers will offer volume discounts, so it’s beneficial to negotiate cost reductions based on higher production quantities.
For example, if your MOQ is 1,000 units, then the price might be $10.00. However, you should also have prices for higher volume. This is how it can look:
1,000 units will cost $10.00unit
5,000 units will cost $9.85/unit
20,000 units will cost $9.60/unit
Cost Reduction Activities
Everybody wants the cost to be lower. Many companies seek cost-down opportunities over time, especially if production scales up. Your contract can include agreements on cost-reduction activities, such as efficiency improvements, material substitutions, or process optimizations. Be clear about when and how these cost-downs should be implemented.
Payment Terms
Clearly defined payment terms help manage cash flow and reduce financial risk. A common type of payment term is Net Payment Terms. This refers to paying the full invoice amount within a set period after shipment, such as NET30, NET60, or NET90. The specific term depends on your relationship with the supplier and their willingness to extend credit.
For example, if your payment terms are NET30, then you’ll pay the invoice in full 30 days after the supplier shipped the product or 30 days after the invoice was created.
Another common method is a combination of a deposit and balance payments. This structure requires partial payments at different stages of production and shipment. A common breakdown can look like this:
30% downpayment upon acceptance of the PO
20% paid on the date of shipment before the goods leave the factory.
50% paid 30 days after receiving the goods.
Currency Fluctuations
If you're purchasing from an international supplier, exchange rate fluctuations can impact pricing. If your supplier operates in a different currency, your contract should address how currency risk is managed. One common approach is to include a clause stating that pricing will remain fixed unless the exchange rate fluctuates beyond a predefined threshold. For example, the contract could state that if the exchange rate shifts by more than ±6% from the rate at the time of signing, the supplier has the right to update pricing accordingly. This ensures that both parties share the currency risk.
Warranty and Liability
Warranty and liability terms are important components of a contract manufacturing agreement as they define the supplier’s responsibility for defective products, performance failures, and potential damages. In this section, you should highlight what the supplier is responsible for and the process for any failures that are due to a manufacturing flaw.
Supplier Warranty Obligations
Your contract should clearly outline the supplier’s warranty obligations, including:
The length of the warranty period (e.g., 12 months from delivery, 18 months from production).
What defects or failures the supplier is responsible for, such as material defects, poor workmanship, or failure to meet agreed specifications.
The process for handling defective products, including repair, replacement, or reimbursement.
For example, it’s common in the consumer electronics space that the supplier warrants the device to be free from defects in materials and assembly for 12 months. If units start failing due to manufacturing and component malfunctions within that period, the supplier would be obligated to replace or repair them at their own cost.
Liability for Defective Products
Defining liability is crucial to ensure that the supplier takes responsibility for issues caused by poor manufacturing. This section should address the following:
Who covers the costs for defective products? Will the supplier replace them for free, issue a credit, or reimburse repair costs?
Threshold for acceptable defect rates: For example, if the agreed rejection rate is 1%, but 5% of products are defective, the supplier must take corrective action.
Who pays for returns or recalls: If defects lead to a recall, does the supplier bear the costs, or is liability shared?
For instance, a company may negotiate that if more than 2% of units fail within the warranty period due to assembly defects, the supplier must cover all replacement costs, including shipping and labor expenses.
Process for Handling Warranty Claims
Your contract should define a clear process for submitting and resolving warranty claims. The process should cover the following:
How defects should be documented (photos, test reports, return samples).
The timeline for reporting issues (e.g., within 30 days of discovery).
The resolution timeframe the supplier must follow (e.g., replacement units shipped within 14 days).
By establishing clear warranty and liability terms, you can protect your business from poor quality and unexpected costs due to errors in the manufacturing process. A well-defined warranty section helps avoid disputes and builds a stronger, more reliable manufacturing partnership.
Engineering Support
Engineering support is essential in a contract manufacturing agreement, especially when the product design requires specific technical expertise, modifications, or optimizations. This section ensures that both parties clearly understand how engineering collaboration will work throughout the manufacturing process. Well-defined engineering support terms help prevent delays, avoid costly mistakes, and improve product quality, ultimately leading to a successful partnership.
Design for Manufacturability (DFM)
One of the key aspects of engineering support is Design for Manufacturability (DFM). DFM is a process in which the supplier’s engineers review your design early in the product development phase to ensure that the design can be manufactured efficiently and at the lowest possible cost. The supplier may suggest design changes that improve production processes, reduce material waste, or make the product easier to assemble.
Engineering Assistance During Production
Ongoing engineering support throughout the production process is crucial for addressing issues that arise during manufacturing. This might include troubleshooting production difficulties, adjusting specifications, or providing solutions to problems related to material sourcing, machine failures, or quality control.
If a component in your product starts to experience failure during the manufacturing process, the supplier’s engineering team should be able to identify the problem and suggest a solution without unnecessary delays. Your agreement should ensure that the supplier provides timely and effective engineering support to avoid production holdups.
Technical Documentation and Updates
It’s also essential that the supplier provides the necessary technical documentation, such as schematics, CAD files, and assembly instructions. Remember, this is your product, so you should have access to all of these documents.
For example, in the case of an electronic device, if your supplier updates the PCB layout during the production run, they should supply updated engineering drawings and documentation. This allows you to stay informed of the changes and ensures consistency across production batches.
Tooling and Equipment Ownership
Tooling and equipment ownership should also be included in the contract manufacturing agreement, especially for companies developing custom products that require specialized molds, dies, or machinery. This section should clearly define the rights and responsibilities related to the creation, use, and ownership of the tooling required for production. Properly addressing tooling ownership in your contract can help avoid potential disputes, ensure that both parties are clear on their obligations, and protect your investment in the manufacturing process.
Tooling Ownership
The contract should specify who owns the tooling at each stage of production. Ownership refers to the rights to the molds, dies, jigs, and other equipment needed to manufacture the product.
For companies that need full control over their production tools, it’s often better to negotiate that tooling is owned by the buyer. This arrangement can provide you with more flexibility to move production to another supplier or make necessary modifications without needing to go through the supplier.
Payment Terms for Tooling
Tooling often requires substantial upfront investment, so it’s important to define payment terms when making these tools. These payments could be structured in different ways, depending on the nature of the tooling and your agreement with the supplier. There are two main ways you can pay for these tools.
The first is paying for the tool upfront. Oftentimes, the buyer is responsible for the cost of tooling, and this cost is either paid in full upfront or split across multiple payments. The contract should specify the payment schedule and amount for tooling.
The second option would be to amortize the cost of the tooling into the product price. In some cases, the tooling cost may be amortized over a certain number of units produced. For example, if the tooling is amortized over 100,000 units, the contract may specify that you pay a higher cost for those first 100,000 units.
Tooling Maintenance and Storage
Tooling often requires regular maintenance to ensure optimal production quality and efficiency. The contract should outline the supplier’s responsibility for maintaining and storing the tooling throughout the manufacturing process.
The contract should state that the supplier is responsible for repairing and maintaining the tooling to prevent wear and tear that could affect the quality of the product. In addition, if tooling is not used for some time, the supplier should store it safely and ensure it remains in good condition. If tooling is not maintained or stored properly, it may result in defects, delays, or increased production costs.
Tooling Transfer and Use with Other Suppliers
If your contract states that you own the tooling, the agreement should also include terms regarding the transfer of the tooling to another supplier if needed. This can happen if you want to move production to a new location, change suppliers, or mitigate risk by diversifying manufacturing sources.
Lead Times and Delivery Commitments
If you are shipping a product, then you will need the supplier to have some consistency on the number of days it takes from the day the PO is placed to the shipment date. In this section, you should have the defined number of days the lead time is, the shipping terms, and safety stock guidelines.
The lead time refers to the amount of time it takes for a supplier to produce and deliver goods after receiving an order. This includes sourcing materials, manufacturing, quality control, and packaging. The contract should specify the standard lead times for production and whether expedited production is available, along with the costs for faster service.
Shipping Terms
The contract should also define the Incoterms, which specify who is responsible for shipping costs and risks at various points during the shipment. Common terms include FOB (Free on Board), CIF (Cost, Insurance, and Freight), and EXW (Ex Works).
For example, if the manufacturing agreement states FOB Shenzhen. This means the supplier is responsible for delivering the products to the port in Shenzhen, and you are responsible for the rest of the shipping process and insurance costs to your destination.
Penalties for Delayed Deliveries
Timely delivery is essential for maintaining the integrity of your business operations. If the supplier fails to meet the agreed-upon lead times or delivery windows, penalties should be clearly outlined in the contract to ensure accountability. Penalties could include late delivery fees, which are typically calculated as a fixed amount for each day of delay beyond the agreed delivery date.
For example, you can structure this clause to look like this for price reductions if the shipment is late:
Number of Days Late | Unit Price Reduction |
14 days or less | No price reduction |
15-28 days late | 4% reduction |
29-42 days late | 5% reduction |
More than 43 days late | 8% reduction |
Stocking and Safety Stock
For products with critical timelines, you may want to negotiate an arrangement for safety stock or buffer inventory. This ensures that the supplier maintains a certain amount of stock in their warehouse to fulfill urgent or unexpected orders quickly, without delays.
Procurement of Long Lead-Time Items
Depending on the product you are building, you might have some parts with longer lead times. These items typically take a longer time to source, produce, or deliver, which can impact the overall manufacturing timeline.
Long lead-time items are materials or components that take a significant amount of time to acquire, often due to factors like scarcity, complexity, or the need for custom manufacturing. These could include specialized electronic components, custom molds, or rare materials that are essential to your product but are not readily available in the market.
For example, the contract might stipulate that you will provide a 6-month forecast of long lead-time components, giving the supplier time to secure the materials and allocate resources for production. The earlier you forecast your needs, the more likely the supplier can maintain a steady flow of components without facing shortages.
Advanced Orders and Payment Terms for Long Lead-Time Items
When dealing with long lead-time items, it’s not uncommon for suppliers to require advanced orders or prepayment to secure these materials, particularly if they need to purchase items from third-party manufacturers or specialty suppliers. The contract should define payment terms for these advanced orders.
Intellectual Property Protection
When dealing with custom products, IP will always be a concern. Safeguarding your proprietary designs, technologies, and concepts ensures that your intellectual property is not misused or compromised in the hands of your contract manufacturer or any of their sub-tier suppliers.
When partnering with a contract manufacturer, you are sharing valuable IP, such as CAD files, your BOM, and product specifications. The agreement should define how the IP will be handled to prevent unauthorized use, copying, or distribution. IP protection clauses in the contract help maintain your competitive advantage and ensure that sensitive information is not leaked or exploited by the supplier.
Ownership of IP
The contract should explicitly state that ownership of all intellectual property related to the product remains with you, the buyer. This includes product designs, prototypes, trademarks, and any patents. If any IP is developed jointly during the production process (such as modifications to designs or new innovations), the contract should outline how that IP will be handled and who holds the rights to it.
Infringement and Legal Recourse
While this is never an easy topic, the contract should outline the steps that will be taken if the IP is infringed upon, either by the manufacturer or by a third party. This could include the requirement that the supplier immediately stop any unauthorized use of your IP and take steps to address the infringement, such as providing compensation or recalling infringing products.
Quality Control
Every company manufacturing a product will look to build a high-quality product. This is not a surprise. A strong quality control and compliance framework not only helps you deliver reliable products to your customers but also protects your brand reputation and ensures you meet all applicable legal requirements.
Quality Standards and Specifications
Your contract should define the specific quality standards that the supplier must meet for each product, including any industry-specific standards relevant to your product. This includes the acceptance criteria for the finished product, as well as the raw materials or components used in manufacturing. Setting clear quality benchmarks will prevent disputes later and ensure that both parties have a mutual understanding of expectations.
Inspection and Testing Procedures
The contract should outline the inspection and testing procedures that the supplier must follow during production, including both in-process and final inspections. This ensures that products meet the agreed-upon specifications and quality levels before they are shipped to you. It is important to define who will be responsible for these inspections, the frequency, and what happens if a product fails the inspection.
Quality Assurance Plans and Documentation
To ensure that the supplier is consistently meeting quality standards, you should request a Quality Assurance (QA) Plan. This plan should detail the supplier’s process for maintaining and improving quality, including the qualifications of their quality control team, their inspection tools, and their quality management systems (such as ISO certifications).
Non-Conformance and Corrective Actions
It is essential to include a process for handling non-conformances in the contract. This refers to situations where the product does not meet the agreed-upon specifications. The supplier should be required to notify you immediately if a non-conformance occurs, and the contract should specify the actions they must take to correct it.
Ongoing Quality Improvement
A good contract should also include provisions for ongoing quality improvement efforts. Manufacturing processes can always be enhanced, and establishing a framework for continuous improvement will help ensure that the supplier continues to meet or exceed your expectations over time. This can include regular reviews of the manufacturing process, joint problem-solving meetings, and investment in new technologies or training for the supplier’s staff.
Conclusion - Negotiate Your Contract Manufacturing Agreement
A well-structured contract manufacturing agreement is crucial for establishing a successful, transparent, and mutually beneficial relationship with your supplier. By clearly defining terms such as pricing, warranty, engineering support, tooling ownership, lead times, procurement of long lead-time items, intellectual property protection, and quality control, you set the groundwork for consistent, high-quality production and safeguard your business interests.
When negotiating these terms, it’s essential to have a shared understanding with your supplier about expectations and obligations. This reduces the likelihood of misunderstandings and disputes, helps you manage risks effectively, and ensures that your product is delivered on time, within budget, and meets your quality standards.
Remember, a contract is more than just a formal agreement—it’s a tool that aligns both parties toward achieving shared goals. As your business relationship evolves, regularly reviewing and updating the terms of your contract will help you build trust with your supplier while ensuring that your production process remains smooth and adaptable to changing circumstances.
By investing time and effort into crafting a comprehensive and clear contract manufacturing agreement, you can set yourself up for long-term success and growth in your manufacturing endeavors.
Comments